Opt Out vs. Object vs. Claim — Which Choice Is Right for You

Every settlement notice gives class members three choices. Here's how each option affects your future legal rights and your potential payout.

The three choices, spelled out

Every class action settlement notice gives every class member three options. You must pick one — even doing nothing is, technically, a fourth option, and it is almost always the wrong one.

Option 1 — File a claim

This is what almost everyone reading this guide should do. You submit a form, the administrator processes it, and you receive your share of the settlement fund. You give up your right to sue the defendant separately for the same conduct.

Option 2 — Opt out (exclude yourself)

You give up any payout from this settlement and keep your right to file your own lawsuit. This makes sense only if you suffered an unusually large, well-documented loss that justifies the cost of bringing a separate case (typically tens of thousands of dollars or more).

Option 3 — Object

You think the settlement is unfair — for example, the payout is too small relative to the harm, or the lawyers are taking too much in fees. You file a written objection with the court. The judge reads it at the fairness hearing and may approve the settlement anyway, modify it, or (rarely) reject it. You can still file a claim and collect your payout while your objection is pending.

Doing nothing — the silent fourth option

If you do nothing, you are bound by the settlement just like everyone who filed a claim, but you receive no money. Your legal rights against the defendant are extinguished. The unclaimed funds are usually redistributed to charities that match the case's subject matter (a "cy pres" distribution), to the federal government, or to the class members who did file claims.

How to actually opt out

Read the official settlement notice. The "Exclusions" section will give you a mailing address and the exact information that must be included in your written request (almost always: your full name, your mailing address, the case caption, and a clear statement that you wish to be excluded). Mail it certified, postmarked on or before the exclusion deadline.

How to actually object

The official notice gives you the requirements. Objections must be in writing, filed with the court (not the administrator), and include your contact information, the case caption, the specific reason for your objection, and any legal authority you rely on. Some judges require a personal appearance at the fairness hearing; others accept written objections only.

Keep reading